Red Wing 1907 vs Red Wing 875 Boots Comparison

Among their iconic offerings, the Red Wing 1907 vs Red Wing 875 are standout models. Both boast excellent craftsmanship and durability, but they cater to slightly different needs. Red Wing is renowned for its premium leather boots, cherished by workers and fashion enthusiasts alike. Let’s dive deep into their features, differences, and how to choose the right one for you.

Red Wing 1907

Introduced in 2005 for Red Wing’s 100th anniversary. Features Copper Rough & Tough leather, an oil-tanned leather known for durability and water resistance. Built on the No. 45 last, offering a roomier fit. Utilizes a Norwegian welt construction for added strength and sturdiness. Includes a removable leather footbed for increased comfort. Employs a Traction Tred outsole for excellent grip.

Red Wing 875

A classic moc toe boot introduced in the 1950s. Crafted with Oro Legacy leather, known for its vibrant orange hue. Built on the No. 23 last, providing a snugger fit. Features a Goodyear welt construction. Employs a Traction Tred outsole. Does not have a removable footbed.

Materials, Leather Type and Construction

Red Wing 1907:

The 1907 is crafted from Copper Rough and Tough leather, which is an oiled rough-out leather that requires minimal maintenance due to its natural oils and waxes. This leather tends to be darker in color.

Red Wing 875:

The 875 utilizes Oro Legacy leather, known for its vibrant orange hue that develops a unique patina over time as it absorbs oils

Comfort

Red Wing 1907:

• The 1907 model prioritizes comfort for all-day wear. Its moc-toe design provides ample toe room, reducing pressure on the feet.
• Features a removable insole, allowing for custom orthotics or additional cushioning.
• Equipped with a soft leather lining that adapts to your foot shape over time.
• Its design allows for extra width and height, catering to those with wider feet.

Red Wing 875:

• The 875 is also built for comfort but has a traditional, non-removable leather insole. Over time, the leather molds to your foot, offering a custom fit.
• The cork midsole provides shock absorption, ideal for long hours on your feet.
• The 875 has a non-removable insole and tends to fit snugly, which might be uncomfortable for some users, especially during the breaking-in period. It is generally considered to have a more classic fit.

Style and Design

Red Wing 1907:

• The 1907 exudes a modern, rugged aesthetic, making it suitable for both work and casual settings.
• Features triple stitching for durability and a moc-toe design with a Goodyear welt construction.
• The copper rough and tough leather develops a unique patina, enhancing its look over time.

Red Wing 875:

• The 875 is a classic Red Wing design, embodying a vintage Americana style.
• Crafted with Oro Legacy leather, it has a slightly shinier finish compared to the 1907.
• The iconic Traction Tred outsole complements its timeless look.

Differences Between Red Wing 1907 and 875 Boots

Feature	Red Wing 1907	Red Wing 875
Leather	Copper Rough and Tough	Oro Legacy
Last	No. 45 (more room)	No. 23 (tighter fit)
Insole	Removable padded	Non-removable
Waterproofing	Excellent (360-degree storm welt)	Good
Weight	67 oz	64 oz
Price	$309.99	$299.99
Breaking-in Period	~10-12 days	~3-4 weeks

For more Comparisons of Red Wing 875 with other red wing boots, explore Red Wing 10875 vs Red Wing 875 Boots Comparison.

Sizing Consistency

Red Wing 1907:

• Tends to run true to size, but it’s recommended to size down half a size for a snug fit.
• Wider fit compared to the 875, making it ideal for broader feet.

Red Wing 875:

• Also runs true to size but has a slightly narrower fit.
• Sizing down half a size ensures a more secure fit after the break-in period.

Red Wing Brand Reputation

Red Wing has been a trusted name in footwear since 1905. Their boots are celebrated for:

• Exceptional craftsmanship: Each pair undergoes rigorous quality checks.
• Heritage appeal: Rooted in American workwear tradition.
• Longevity: Many users report wearing their Red Wings for over a decade with proper care.

Breathability

Red Wing 1907:

• The soft leather lining offers moderate breathability. While not as airy as athletic shoes, it prevents excessive sweating during regular wear.

Red Wing 875:

• Slightly less breathable due to the thicker Oro Legacy leather. However, the natural materials help regulate temperature, especially in cooler climates.

Durability

Both models excel in durability, thanks to their Goodyear welt construction and premium leather.

Red Wing 1907:

• Features the Vibram mini-lug sole, which offers excellent traction and longevity on varied terrains. The soles of the red wing1907 are softer, which may lead to faster wear

Red Wing 875:

• The Traction Tred outsole is durable but better suited for smooth surfaces like concrete or wood.  Red Wing 875 provides good but slightly less effective waterproofing

Fit and Support

Red Wing 1907:

• Offers a more forgiving fit, especially for wider feet.
• The removable insole adds flexibility in achieving the perfect support.

Red Wing 875:

• Provides excellent arch support but requires a longer break-in period for optimal comfort.
• The narrower fit might feel restrictive initially but adapts over time.

Red Wing 1907 vs Red Wing 875 Pricing Comparison

Feature	Red Wing 1907	Red Wing 875
Price Range	$320 – $350	$300 – $330
Value for Money	Higher due to modern features	Excellent for classic boot lovers

Both models represent a significant investment, but their durability and timeless appeal make them worth every penny.

Customer Reviews

Red Wing 1907:

• Many users praise its comfort and modern design.
• Popular among those who need versatile boots for work and casual wear.
• The removable insole is a big hit with customers.

Red Wing 875:

• Highly regarded for its classic style and heritage look.
• Some customers mention the longer break-in period but love the eventual fit.
• The Traction Tred outsole receives mixed reviews for grip on slippery surfaces.

Conclusion

Choosing between the Red Wing 1907 and 875 depends on your preferences and needs. If you prioritize comfort, modern aesthetics, and a forgiving fit, the Red Wing 1907 is your go-to. However, if you’re drawn to classic Americana style and don’t mind a longer break-in period, the Red Wing 875 is a perfect choice.

Both models are exceptional in quality, ensuring you’ll enjoy them for years to come.

FAQs

1. Are Red Wing boots worth the price? Yes, Red Wing boots are crafted with premium materials and offer unmatched durability, making them a worthwhile investment.

2. How long does it take to break in Red Wing boots? It typically takes 2-4 weeks of regular wear to break in Red Wing boots, depending on the model.

3. Can I replace the insoles in Red Wing 875 boots? No, the 875 features a non-removable leather insole, which molds to your feet over time.

4. Which boot is better for wider feet? The Red Wing 1907 is better suited in comparison to 875 for wider feet due to its roomier design.

5. How do I care for Red Wing boots? Regularly clean your boots with a damp cloth, condition the leather to prevent cracking, and use a boot brush for polishing.

Both the 1907 and 875 are excellent choices, offering unique benefits to suit different needs. Whichever you choose, rest assured you’ll own a piece of footwear history.